08/05/2021    Jon Hultman, DPM

We Have Met the Enemy and It Is Us

Taking and passing the USMLE is the true path to
parity. DPMs are the only healthcare practitioners
whose training includes a minimum of four years of
podiatric medical school and three years of
residency training that do not hold a plenary
medical license. Because of this, DPMs are not
considered physicians, are lumped with
chiropractors and optometrists as providers of
optional services under Medicaid, and must
constantly amend state bills to include DPMs
whenever those bills use the term “physician.”
Every advancement that has been made in podiatric
medicine has been considered a victory because it
gave DPMs a benefit or privilege that MDs and DOs
already had. This process has moved us
incrementally closer to MDs and DOs, but in spite
all these small “victories,” this will not win our
“war for parity.”

The only achievable pathways that have been
available for DPMs to attain true parity with MDs
and DOs were to go to LCME accredited medical or a
COCA accredited osteopathic schools to obtain MD or
DO degrees, or to obtain a dual degree by taking
additional years of education at an osteopathic/DPM
school. Interestingly, in addition to more years of
education, these pathways to parity both require
taking and passing either the USMLE or the COMLEX
exam. Once a doctor has obtained a dual MD/DPM
degree, s/he still does not have a medical license.
To obtain a medical license also requires
completion of an ACGME approved residency program.
If a DPM actually wants to practice podiatric
medicine and surgery, s/he also needs to take a
CPME approved podiatric residency.

To avoid these extra years of medical school and
residency programs, a process was begun in
California over ten years ago through the
initiation of a task force that includes the
California Medical Association, the California
Orthopedic Association, the Osteopathic Physicians
and Surgeons of California, and the California
Podiatric Medical Associations. The initial
“impossible” hurdles for this task force to
overcome were (1) the podiatric schools would need
to be accredited by the LCME, (2) the residency
programs would need to be accredited by the ACGME,
and (3) graduates would need to take and pass the
USMLE.

Of course, to be accredited by the LCME, the
podiatric schools would need to become medical
schools. That option was unacceptable. Following
in depth visits by the task force representatives
to the two California podiatric medical schools and
four residency programs, the consensus was that the
sequencing of DPM education was different from that
of MDs and DOS because podiatric students choose
their specialty at the beginning of their
educational process. It was clear that by the end
of the educational process DPMs were comparable to
those in other surgical specialties of medicine.
The end consensus of the members of the California
Task Force was that if the accrediting standards of
CPME were found to be comparable to LCME and ACGME
(which we believe they are), the medical and
orthopedic associations agreed that they would
accept CPME as the accrediting body. The only
requirement left would be to take and pass the
USMLE; however, as it stands today DPMs cannot take
the USMLE. Because access to the USMLE is a
national issue, CPMA submitted the USMLE resolution
to the APMA House of Delegates for action. After
passing, this resolution was subsequently adopted
by the National Task Force consisting of APMA,
ACFAS, AAOS, and AOFAS.

The goal at this point in time is to simply to gain
access to the test.
The pathway to parity that California supports is
the current one being pursued by the National Task
Force. That is: CPME would remain as the
accrediting body for the colleges and residency
programs, no additional years of education beyond
seven would be required, the pathway would be
inclusive so that the USMLE would be an option for
all DPMs who wanted to study and prepare for the
exam, and the DPM degree would become the third
degree to qualify for a plenary medical license –
hence, DPM=MD=DO. The end result is that DPMs
would be included in all statutes where the term
“physician” is used, they would become R1 instead
of R3 physicians under Medicare, their services
would become mandatory under Medicaid, and DPMs
would have true parity with MDs and DOs.

Without seizing this opportunity now, as we go into
the future, DPMs will continue to be considered
“non-physicians” – lumped with chiropractors and
optometrists as optional services under Medicaid,
and because they have a limited license, they will
be doomed to fight battles each and every year just
to retain previous gains or to advance small steps
– one at a time – trying to move ever closer to MDs
and DOs. If you were a college student trying to
decide on a career, would you choose a specialty
that requires seven to eight years of education and
in which, upon graduation, its members would be
considered non-physicians and practitioners of the
only surgical specialty that holds a limited
license?

One question I have for those who oppose this
pathway – especially those who consider themselves
to be visionaries and say they want what is best
for our specialty – is, “What other credible
alternative to true parity do you suggest?” Our
profession has been talking about and working
towards parity with MDs and DOs for my 50-year
history as a DPM, but I have yet to see any other
credible plan on the table that is actually
achievable and has momentum. It has taken us ten
years to get to a point that many in the past have
considered to be impossible. Do we simply abandon
this process, happy with the status quo, for the
next 50 years?

Jon Hultman, DPM, Executive Director, California
Podiatric Medical Association